Action for Victims of Chiropractic
Victims Complaints Legal Advice Medical Support
 
Introduction
Case Studies
Members - UK

Frances Denoon

Click to access below

Miss H (Name withheld)

Linda Barter

MS IK (name withheld)

Kathryn McGlynn

Margaret (name witheld)

  Victims - Case Studies
 
 

All stories in this section have been reproduced with the kind permission of the Victims.

 
 

Frances Denoon's -  case study 

I AM 0.6 IN A MILLION (APPARENTLY) Quote “Junior Minister of Heath February 2001”

Mrs Frances Denoon (now aged 31) recalls of her recovery from major brain surgery and a brain stem stroke.

An innocent visit to a Registered Chiropractor in Bristol in March 1998 led to an incredible series of events that seemed fictional in nature. It all started as I practiced my favourite pastime “keep fit” at a local sport centre, when, ouch, I pulled a nerve or something in my neck. The next day it seemed to ache and progressively led to a headache and stopped me from going to work. After a couple of days I visited my GP who gave me painkillers after diagnosing a trapped nerve and rest. One late night it became excruciating and my husband was worried enough to take me to casualty I was so distressed. The hospital gave me stronger painkillers, agreed it was nothing serious and I felt better.

A few more uncomfortable days past and I returned to my GP who gave me stronger painkillers and anti-inflammatories, also recommending Chiropractor could help. I scanned the yellow pages for a Registered Chiropractor, found one and made an appointment. The first visit was uneventful, the second was catastrophic.

My world went into a dizzy spin as nausea and loss of speech overtook me after a gut wrenching “crack” as the Chiropractor used his trained skills, to thrust my neck vertebrae to cure my headache and trapped nerve.

Clearly for him something was wrong. Not so clearly for me, I assumed part of the treatment. After vomiting insued and a GP from the local practice looked at me I was rushed to Frenchay Hospital.

“you’ll be OK, you’ll be fine” the Chiropractor voice merging with the Ambulance crews radio and generally now, vision impaired world, that was to be mine for the next 6 months.

What happens over the next 24 hours is not from my memory, but from my husband, family and the three volumes of medical notes and 100 X-rays that sit neatly in my cupboard at home now.

This is where the incredible skills of the NHS clearly come to light as the wheels  were set in motion to see want an earth was up with me. I led on the trolley as Doctors peered into my eyes with their lightpens, blood pressure taken…oops vomited again….needles, blood tests.. by now my vision was poor and I felt very scared. I couldn’t  hardly speak. Then my husband Richard arrived. At last comforting hand to hold. I was rushed for an Angiogram as the Doctor’s could see that I was having a neurological “event”.  The Angiogram indicated that I had a tear in my vertebral artery caused by the Chiropractor treatment and a clot was forming. My veins where pumped with anti-clotting drugs and I was sent of to the ward to let the drugs do their work. I remember little details, ladies talking in the wards, my family members, but I couldn’t see only hear. I felt awful but assured that I would wake up and all would be fine. The next day more observations & tests. I felt more tired now and wanted to be left to sleep as I slowly drifted into unconscious state. Around me a growing anxiety as I deteriorated during the day. The clot grew and induced a brain stem stroke in my cerebellum. I lost consciousness, went into a coma, I was in critical condition.

The Consultants and Neurosurgeons discussed, my family informed in a tearful huddle, and I was whisked away for Brain Surgery to safe my life.

My brain was swelling around the site of the stroke and brain fluid was unable to escape which if not corrected, would kill me. Perhaps rather crude, a drill bore into my skull above my left ear (burr hole) to relieve fluid. At the same time, the surgeons opened the back of my skull to remove dead tissue from the stroke affected area, and, allow my swollen brain chance to recover.

Was I to survive, clearly I have, did anyone think I would ?. Well, the Medics were surprised and put my survival at 50/50. My family where devastated. Why was this happening, is it common ?. I made it through the 3 hour operation and was duly connected to a battery of wires and beeping machines, life support and god knows what. My Mum, Dad and Husband brought in to see me intensive care.

I was led on my back, eyes closed, tube in my head, life support tube in my mouth tied tightly, tubes in veins, wires everywhere, all to keep my alive after such a massive shock to the body.

I knew nothing of course, but I remember a reoccurring dream of being on a ship, a ship perhaps with an unclear destination. The Doctors grimly advised my ashen faced family that the next 24 hours could be my exit from the world or not. The ship sailed on…through storms in my dream…..rolling and rocking. By now news of my health had spread to wider circle of family and friends, who now were sharing in my close families shock as they pondered the news. A relay team of close family sat with me as I steered my dream ship to destination “recovery.”

I opened my eyes the next day to relief of all. My husband peered into them hopefully and my left t eye lost control and involuntarily moved. A bit unnerving and frightening for him. I’m still dreaming. A quick reassurance from the Consultant, that it would correct and hearts lifted. I moved hurrah, and the Doctors slowly weaned me of the life support. I gradually improved although groggy. It took my Brother & Brother in Law  to shake me from my ship dream. They made remarks about my car and I suddenly wanted to be involved. This was  my awakening and I became much more alert. My family hearts lifted, I was going to recover.

My next operation ( don’t forget I can’t remember at this time) was a “trachy” (the hole they make in your wind pipe so you can breathe). I couldn’t swallow, so saliva was entering my lungs. But I was getting a bit more with it and attempting to communicate more. Nasal feed tube kept the calories coming in. Catheter for urine kept the fluids going out. Not sure about number two’s. A few ward moves as I improved. It was around this time a few memories occur and I clearly knew I was in hospital. I knew I had clot. I knew I had an operation. I didn’t know that a piece of my brain had been sucked out and I was permanently damaged and had a stroke. Still onward and yippee.. I sat out in a chair, my sight was coming back, I felt I was getting better. Still the dreams of the ship, Doctors & nurses where my passengers. My emotionally exhausted family and drained husband Richard ( who had only lost his mother a few months before ) beamed as I improved enough to attempt physiotherapy. Gone with the removal of the grey matter went my right side balance, right hand/leg coordination. Still couldn’t swallow, couldn’t speak with the tube in my throat, but good news, my sight was much better.

Two weeks into the medical drama and the ship dream passed and reality took hold. I couldn’t walk. Why not?. I didn’t understand. What’s wrong with my right arm? It shakes !. Tubes and blood tests. What a drag. Warfarin (blood thinner) pumped through my veins as the residual clot was dissolving. My family tried to explain what is going on. Then…vomit. Oh no what now. I had now a reaction to the nasal feed tube. Vomit again and again. Doctors became concerned and my strength was sapped. Oh no.. another operation looming. A gastric fed tube direct through my skin into my tummy. That was sore, but it did the trick and I became stronger again. More physio, tests, injections, blood letting and hurrah, my swallow reflex returned slowly, trachy breath tube out and I could sip drinks. Sight was nearly normal and yippee I could speak. Nothing was going to stop me now, I worked at everything they gave me, over and over, encouraged by family and results. Repetitions of exercises whilst the ward slept. Up arm down arm, squeeze fist over and over. Must teach my brain to control my hand. Days and days passed…I stood and took a few steps. Started to eat soft food, I wanted to leave hospital.

I left hospital in May, 8 weeks after entering…never angry why me?, only must get better. Want to be as I was !. Exercises will get me there. The next 6 months I walked and exercised daily. Today 3 years on, I have a constant battle on the inside, to keep balance, arm control ,speech and thoughts together, however to the unknowing, a normal woman on the outside.

The legal case is discussed under Legal - My Case in this website.